Best Picture
Battle #1:
A Beautiful Mind vs.
The Lord Of The Rings: The
Fellowship Of The Ring
I'm not claiming to know who will win
in this category or any other category
for that matter. It's just becoming
increasingly clear who is pulling
ahead of the pack.
So, with what has
occurred in the lesser of the award
shows (and boy, is it just me, or is
there just way too many award shows? I
can do with just the Oscars and the
Golden Globes), here is a list of who
and what I feel will at least be
front-runners and even who will
probably win, along with the reasons
why.
If you look at what critics say,
Lord of the Rings should win hands
down. When a movie is reviewed by 110
critics and 95% of them recommend it
(refer to RottenTomatoes.com), you
know you have one great movie. Also,
the movie still seemed like a long
shot until it won the very first AFI
best picture award. All of the sudden
it became one of the front-runners.
Never mind Mullholland Drive
winning three best pictures (Boston
Society Of Film Critics, NY Film
Critics Circle, National Society Of
Film Critics) or Moulin Rouge
(National Board) and In The Bedroom
(Los Angeles Film Critics) winning one
each before LOTR won its first. Of
the movies that will get nominated,
LOTR is by far my favorite. If Memento
were to be nominated it would be a
tough choice for me. But
unfortunately, Memento has a very
small chance of being nominated (due
to coming out early in the year and
not getting much Oscar push from its
small company). LOTR still stands a
pretty good chance of winning but it
will be tough, as there are no stars
that will be nominated (even though I
believe Ian Mckellen gave one of the
best performances of the year). But
with Peter Jackson sure to be
nominated for Best Director (making an
outstanding picture when no one
believed it could be done), the movie
will at least get nominated as well.
Although A Beautiful Mind
received a less than stellar 78% on
RottenTomatoes, and not winning a Best
Picture award until after the
aforementioned, it has clearly become
a favorite to win the "big one". Let's
just say that Universal Pictures has
done a magnificent job of promoting
the movie to the voters of the Golden
Globes and will most likely continue
promoting it for the Oscars. There are
many things that count against the
movie. Rumors that it doesn't really
show everything that went on in John
Forbes Nash Jr.'s life are casting
some doubts as to how well the movie
follows his legend. But does that
really matter? Not according to
Broadcast Film Critics Association or
the Golden Globes, which both gave it
the Best Picture award. One thing that
counts for Mind is that it will also
receive two actor nominations (for
Russell Crowe and Jennifer Connelly)
and most likely for Best Director, Ron
Howard. So the movie will get a lot of
exposure. But it doesn't always mean
that a movie will win if it has many
acting nominations. Yet, there is
still this feeling that this is the
movie to beat this year. And as it
continues to stay among the top
grossing movies, the buzz just grows
more deafening.
But don't count out Moulin Rouge,
as it has become a late bloomer with
what seems like major Oscar buzz. The
movie recently won the Golden Globe
for Best Picture in the musical or
comedy category. It also won Actress
in a Leading Role (Musical or Comedy)
for Nicole Kidman. But alas, the movie
received a major blow. Nicole Kidman
was not nominated for the prestigious
SAG awards.
Other films that I see standing a very
good chance of at least getting
nominated are:
Mulholland Drive; it's been
nominated by almost every award
institution and as I stated above, has
won three times. The only thing is
that the movie might just be too weird
for older academy voters.
In the Bedroom
I do not fully agree with all critics
but the movie did receive a 92% rating
on RottenTomatoes. And now with Nicole
Kidman taking a knife in the back from
her peers, Sissy Spacek has a clear
road to victory for lead actress.
Gosford Park -
Robert Altman has been a favorite with
critics and voters for a long time (as
is evident with several wins for Best
Director and glowing reviews for the
film) and this year seems no
different. Although the movie has not
won any awards so far it might squeak
in with a nomination.
Black Hawk Down -
This is another one of those
movies that has received a major push
for consideration as of late. But once
again, I don't think the older academy
members will like it too much for its
graphic depiction of war, no matter
how patriotic the movie is.
The Five Movies I Believe Will
Be Nominated:
- A Beautiful Mind
- Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship
of the Ring
- In the Bedroom
- Moulin Rouge
- Mulholland Drive
Deserving, But Will Be Left Out:
- Memento
- The Others
- The Royal Tenenbaums
Who I Want To Win:
- Lord of the Rings or Memento
And The Award Goes To:
- A Beautiful Mind