|
|
|
|
Ian McKellen |
|
by E. Charl Hattingh
Supporting Actor
Battle #6: Jim Broadbent vs. Ethan
Hawke vs. Ben Kingsley
Yes, this is one of the more
interesting races in Oscar this year,
but isn't it always. In other categories
it is sometimes easy to kind of predict
who will win, but Supporting Actor
always seems to be filled with its share
of great performances. |
|
Jim Broadbent who starred in
both Moulin Rouge and Iris (for which
he is nominated) has already lined up
some awards in the pre-Oscar award
shows, with three in total (The Golden
Globes, Los Angeles Film Critics
Association and National Board of
Review of Motion Pictures). His
performance in Iris must be superb to
seemingly outshine that of legendary
actress, Judi Dench, and it seems that
he might just walk away with the
Supporting Actor Oscar in doing so. I
myself haven't even seen the movie,
but from the way that other critics
have talked about the performance, it
sounds pretty good. It also helps that
he wasn't up for Best Actor instead.
Ben Kingsley is probably most
remembered for playing the role of
Gandhi in 1983 for which he won Best
Actor. So wouldn't it be ironic if he
won his second Oscar for playing a
violent gangster? Kingsley has already
won two awards this year for his role
in Sexy Beast (Boston Society of Film
Critics and Broadcast Film Critics
Association) and both Ebert and Roeper
really liked his performance as well.
So, could Kingsley finally win his
second Oscar almost twenty years after
receiving his first? Well, his chances
are pretty good I would say.
Ehtan Hawke has chosen many
independent type movies throughout his
career. That's where actors usually
turn to so they can get noticed by the
Academy. So it turns out to be kind of
ironic that he gets nominated in a
mainstream movie such as Training Day.
It is also strange that he received
the nomination after other actors like
Steve Buscemi have received awards for
roles already this year, and he
hasn't. In fact, this is only his
second nomination for the role. Most
academy members will most likely look
at how young he is and decide that he
will be better fit to win the award
sometime in the future.
Ian McKellen is my choice all
the way. Just like Hawke, this is only
his second nomination for the year but
in what most observers must find
astonishing, he walked away with the
Screen Actors Guild Award. So,
naturally, his stock must have risen
due to this unexpected award. I have
long talked about how great he was in
LOTR and that I want him to be
nominated for an Oscar, but as all the
awards took place early in the year,
he was nowhere to be found. Then all
of the sudden he gets nominated in two
of the biggest award shows, and he
wins one. And if LOTR walks away with
many awards on Oscar night, McKellen
could be one of them. I certainly hope
so, since he brought a presence to the
screen that somehow stood above the
other performances, the effects and
the story. And another thing that
counts for him is that he is a veteran
that has been nominated before.
Jon Voight is an outstanding
actor, there's no doubt about
that. Some of the transformations he's
made in recent movies are mesmerizing.
I still don't believe that it is him
in Ali, but unfortunately the movie
did way below expectations and that is
what will count against him come Oscar
night. But I believe that he will some
day win again (he won once for Lead
Actor for Coming Home in 1979). This
is just not his year.
Deserved to Be Nominated But Was
Left Out:
-Steve Buscemi (Ghost World)
-Edward Norton (The Score)
-Tim Roth (Planet of the Apes)
Who I Want to Win:
-Ian McKellen
And the Award Goes to:
-Ben Kingsley (I think?)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|